In a series of events highlighting the escalating value and demand for Pokémon trading cards, a Missouri man has been arrested and charged following the theft of merchandise worth hundreds of dollars from local retailers.
Incident Overview
On January 9, law enforcement responded to a theft report at the Dollar General located at 3400 Missouri 13 in Higginsville.
Surveillance footage revealed two individuals entering the store; one suspect proceeded behind the counter, seizing display boxes of Pokémon cards and exiting without payment. The stolen items were valued at over $200.
Further Investigations
Subsequent investigations uncovered that the same duo had earlier targeted a Walmart store, absconding with more than $150 in Pokémon cards and related merchandise.
A review of online marketplaces led authorities to discover that Vantine had attempted to sell the stolen items on Facebook Marketplace.
Arrest and Charges
On January 10, officers located Vantine’s vehicle at a Pilot Travel Center in Higginsville. Both suspects were found inside the establishment’s McDonald’s.
A search of their vehicle yielded a substantial quantity of Pokémon cards, drug paraphernalia, methamphetamine, and a rifle. Vantine was subsequently arrested and charged with:
- Two counts of burglary
- Two counts of stealing
- Possession of a controlled substance
- Unlawful use of a weapon
If convicted on all charges, Vantine could face up to 25 years in prison.
Rise in Pokémon Card-Related Crimes
The surge in popularity and value of Pokémon trading cards has led to a notable increase in thefts.
- In September 2022, Nicholas Garrison was charged with stealing over $12,000 worth of Pokémon cards from a Crestwood store.
- In February 2025, an organized crime syndicate in Melbourne, Australia, allegedly stole approximately $50,000 worth of collectible trading cards, including Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards.
The case of Johnathan R. Vantine underscores the increasing trend of crimes associated with the lucrative market of Pokémon trading cards.
As the value of these collectibles continues to rise, retailers and collectors alike must remain vigilant against potential thefts and fraudulent activities.